Explore the intricacies of pricing and valuation of futures and forwards, focusing on the cost-of-carry model, pricing relationships, and arbitrage opportunities.

On this page

Futures and forwards are fundamental financial instruments used for hedging and speculation in the financial markets. Understanding their pricing and valuation is crucial for investors, traders, and financial professionals. This section delves into the cost-of-carry model, the relationship between spot and futures prices, factors influencing futures prices, and the role of arbitrage in maintaining market efficiency.

The cost-of-carry model is a cornerstone in the pricing of futures and forwards. It posits that the futures price of an asset is determined by the spot price and the cost of carrying the asset until the delivery date. The cost of carry includes:

**Storage Costs:**Expenses incurred to store the physical commodity.**Financing Costs:**The opportunity cost of capital tied up in holding the asset, often represented by the risk-free interest rate.**Convenience Yield:**The non-monetary benefits of holding the physical asset, such as ensuring supply availability.

Mathematically, the cost-of-carry model can be expressed as:

$$ F = S \times e^{(r + c - y) \times t} $$

Where:

- \( F \) is the futures price.
- \( S \) is the spot price.
- \( r \) is the risk-free interest rate.
- \( c \) is the storage cost.
- \( y \) is the convenience yield.
- \( t \) is the time to maturity in years.
- \( e \) is the base of the natural logarithm.

The relationship between spot prices and futures prices is pivotal in understanding futures markets. The futures price is essentially the present value of the expected future spot price, adjusted for the cost of carry. The basic formula for pricing futures is:

$$ F = S \times e^{r \times t} $$

This formula assumes no storage costs or convenience yield and is primarily applicable to financial futures. The exponential function \( e^{r \times t} \) represents the compounding effect of the risk-free interest rate over time.

Several factors can cause futures prices to deviate from spot prices:

**Interest Rates:**Higher interest rates increase the cost of carry, leading to higher futures prices.**Storage Costs:**Commodities with significant storage costs, such as oil or grains, will have higher futures prices.**Income/Yield from Asset:**Assets generating income, like dividends or coupons, reduce the futures price since the holder of the futures contract does not receive these benefits.

To better understand the application of these concepts, let’s consider examples of calculating futures prices for different types of assets.

Suppose the spot price of a stock index is $1,000, the risk-free interest rate is 5% per annum, and the time to maturity is six months (0.5 years). The futures price can be calculated as:

$$ F = 1000 \times e^{0.05 \times 0.5} $$

$$ F = 1000 \times e^{0.025} $$

$$ F \approx 1000 \times 1.0253 $$

$$ F \approx 1025.30 $$

Thus, the futures price of the stock index is approximately $1,025.30.

Consider a commodity with a spot price of $50, a risk-free rate of 4%, storage cost of 2%, and a convenience yield of 1%. The time to maturity is one year. The futures price is:

$$ F = 50 \times e^{(0.04 + 0.02 - 0.01) \times 1} $$

$$ F = 50 \times e^{0.05} $$

$$ F \approx 50 \times 1.0513 $$

$$ F \approx 52.57 $$

The futures price for the commodity is approximately $52.57.

Arbitrage plays a critical role in ensuring that futures prices remain aligned with theoretical values. Arbitrage opportunities arise when there is a discrepancy between the theoretical futures price and the actual market price. Traders can exploit these differences to earn risk-free profits, thereby driving the market back to equilibrium.

Assume the theoretical futures price of a commodity is $52.57, but the market price is $54. An arbitrageur could:

- Sell the futures contract at $54.
- Buy the commodity at the spot price of $50.
- Hold the commodity until the futures contract matures, incurring a cost of carry of $2.57.

At maturity, the arbitrageur delivers the commodity against the futures contract, realizing a profit of:

$$ \text{Profit} = 54 - (50 + 2.57) = 1.43 $$

This arbitrage opportunity will prompt traders to sell futures and buy the spot commodity, adjusting prices until the arbitrage opportunity is eliminated.

Understanding the pricing and valuation of futures and forwards is essential for navigating the financial markets. The cost-of-carry model provides a framework for determining futures prices, while the relationship between spot and futures prices highlights the influence of various factors. Arbitrage ensures that futures prices remain aligned with theoretical values, maintaining market efficiency.

### What is the cost-of-carry model used for?
- [x] Pricing futures and forwards
- [ ] Determining stock dividends
- [ ] Calculating bond yields
- [ ] Evaluating real estate investments
> **Explanation:** The cost-of-carry model is used to price futures and forwards by considering the spot price and the cost of carrying the asset until delivery.
### Which of the following is NOT a component of the cost of carry?
- [ ] Storage costs
- [ ] Financing costs
- [x] Dividend yield
- [ ] Convenience yield
> **Explanation:** Dividend yield is not a component of the cost of carry. It is related to the income from holding an asset, which affects futures pricing differently.
### How does an increase in interest rates affect futures prices?
- [x] Increases futures prices
- [ ] Decreases futures prices
- [ ] Has no effect on futures prices
- [ ] Only affects spot prices
> **Explanation:** Higher interest rates increase the cost of carry, leading to higher futures prices.
### What is the formula for calculating the futures price without storage costs or convenience yield?
- [x] \\( F = S \times e^{r \times t} \\)
- [ ] \\( F = S + r \times t \\)
- [ ] \\( F = S \times (1 + r \times t) \\)
- [ ] \\( F = S - e^{r \times t} \\)
> **Explanation:** The formula \\( F = S \times e^{r \times t} \\) calculates the futures price considering only the risk-free interest rate and time to maturity.
### What role does arbitrage play in futures markets?
- [x] Ensures prices remain aligned with theoretical values
- [ ] Increases market volatility
- [ ] Reduces liquidity
- [ ] Determines interest rates
> **Explanation:** Arbitrage helps maintain market efficiency by ensuring that futures prices remain aligned with theoretical values.
### Which factor would decrease the futures price of a commodity?
- [ ] Higher storage costs
- [ ] Higher interest rates
- [x] Higher convenience yield
- [ ] Longer time to maturity
> **Explanation:** A higher convenience yield reduces the futures price because it represents the benefits of holding the physical asset.
### What happens when the market futures price is lower than the theoretical futures price?
- [x] Arbitrageurs buy futures and sell the spot asset
- [ ] Arbitrageurs sell futures and buy the spot asset
- [ ] No arbitrage opportunity exists
- [ ] Futures prices increase further
> **Explanation:** Arbitrageurs exploit the opportunity by buying futures and selling the spot asset until prices align.
### In the cost-of-carry model, what does the variable \\( t \\) represent?
- [x] Time to maturity in years
- [ ] The risk-free interest rate
- [ ] The spot price
- [ ] The storage cost
> **Explanation:** The variable \\( t \\) represents the time to maturity in years.
### Which of the following would cause a futures price to be higher than the spot price?
- [x] High storage costs
- [ ] High dividend yield
- [ ] Low interest rates
- [ ] Negative convenience yield
> **Explanation:** High storage costs increase the cost of carry, leading to a higher futures price compared to the spot price.
### True or False: Arbitrage opportunities can lead to risk-free profits.
- [x] True
- [ ] False
> **Explanation:** Arbitrage opportunities arise from price discrepancies, allowing traders to earn risk-free profits by executing specific strategies.

Monday, October 28, 2024