Cash Accounts and Margin Accounts
1. Define Cash and Margin Accounts
A securities transaction through a dealer member must be made in either a cash account or a margin account. Below, we elaborate on the defining features and operational differences between the two:
Cash Accounts
Clients with regular cash accounts are expected to make full payment for purchases or full delivery for sales on or before the settlement date. The settlement date is specified in the contract, generally according to the following industry rules:
- Government of Canada Treasury bills: On the day the transaction takes place
- All other securities: Two business days after the transaction takes place (often referred to as T+2)
This underscores the need for clients to have sufficient funds or securities on hand to meet these obligations.
Margin Accounts
In contrast, margin accounts are used by clients who wish to buy or sell securities on partial credit. Here:
- The client pays only a portion of the purchase price.
- The investment dealer lends the balance to the client, thereby charging interest on the loan.
This allows leverage, enabling clients to potentially increase their return on investment, but also exposes them to higher levels of risk.
Key Differences Between Cash Accounts and Margin Accounts
The distinction between cash accounts and margin accounts can have significant implications for investors:
| Feature |
Cash Account |
Margin Account |
| Payment Requirement |
Full payment required by settlement date (no credit granted) |
Partial payment with remaining balance financed by the dealer (credit extended) |
| Interest |
No interest on transactions |
Interest charged on the borrowed amount |
| Risk |
Lower risk, less leverage |
Higher risk, more leverage |
Settlement Date
The settlement date is the date by which the transaction must be finalized. Depending on the security type, these dates can vary:
| Type of Security |
Settlement Date |
| Government of Canada Treasury bills |
On the transaction date |
| All other securities |
Two business days post transaction |
Initial Margin Requirement
When opening a margin position, the initial margin requirement signifies the minimum amount an investor must deposit. For example:
$$
\text{Initial Margin Requirement} = \text{Purchase Price} \times \text{Margin Rate}
$$
If the purchase price of a security is $10,000 and the margin rate is 50%, the initial margin would be:
$$
10{,}000 \times 0.50 = 5{,}000
$$
Maintenance Margin
The maintenance margin is the minimum amount that must be maintained in the margin account. If the value of securities falls, additional funds may be needed to cover this margin.
Key Takeaways
- Cash accounts require full payment or delivery by the settlement date, offering lower risk since no credit is extended.
- Margin accounts enable trading on credit, allowing for leverage but also introducing higher risk due to borrowing associated costs and potential for significant losses.
- Understanding the difference and implications of cash versus margin accounts is vital for effective financial planning and risk management.
FAQs
What happens if I don’t have enough funds in my cash account by the settlement date?
If you don’t have enough funds in your cash account by the settlement date, your broker may sell your securities to meet the obligation, which can lead to unwanted fee implications.
Can I avoid paying interest on margin accounts?
Interest on margin accounts accrues on the borrowed amount. To avoid paying interest, you can reduce or eliminate your margin balances by paying off the amount borrowed as quickly as possible.
What is the maximum leverage I can use with a margin account?
The maximum leverage varies between institutions, but typically, the buying power can be double (50%) of your deposited margin funds. SROs set specific regulations on these limits.
Glossary
- Settlement Date: The date when a trade must be finalized, and ownership is officially transferred.
- Margin Rate: The percentage required to be deposited by an investor when purchasing on margin.
- Initial Margin Requirement: The initial amount that needs to be deposited to purchase securities in a margin account.
- Maintenance Margin: The minimum equity amount required in a margin account.
By understanding the nuances between cash and margin accounts, investors can make more informed decisions relative to their risk tolerance and investment strategies.
📚✨ Quiz Time! ✨📚
## What distinguishes a cash account from a margin account in securities trading?
- [ ] In a cash account, clients use partial credit to make purchases.
- [ ] In a margin account, clients must make full payment by the settlement date.
- [x] In a margin account, the client buys or sells securities on partial credit.
- [ ] Margin accounts do not allow the use of credit for transactions.
> **Explanation:** In a cash account, full payment must be made by the settlement date. In contrast, a margin account allows clients to use partial credit, borrowing a portion from the investment dealer.
## When must clients with regular cash accounts make full payment for purchases?
- [ ] On the transaction date.
- [ ] The day after the transaction date.
- [x] On or before the settlement date.
- [ ] A week after the transaction date.
> **Explanation:** Clients with regular cash accounts are expected to make full payment for purchases on or before the settlement date.
## What happens if a transaction involves Government of Canada Treasury bills?
- [x] The transaction is settled on the same day.
- [ ] The transaction is settled three business days after.
- [ ] Full payment is required seven days after.
- [ ] The transaction has no specified settlement date.
> **Explanation:** Transactions involving Government of Canada Treasury bills must be settled on the day the transaction takes place.
## How are all other securities, apart from Government of Canada Treasury bills, settled?
- [ ] On the day the transaction takes place.
- [ ] Four business days after the transaction.
- [ ] Three business days after the transaction.
- [x] Two business days after the transaction.
> **Explanation:** All other securities, apart from Government of Canada Treasury bills, settle two business days after the transaction takes place.
## What must clients with cash accounts do when selling securities?
- [ ] Deliver the securities within a week.
- [ ] Rely on an extension for delivery.
- [x] Make full delivery by the settlement date.
- [ ] Deliver partial securities and settle the rest later.
> **Explanation:** Clients with cash accounts must make full delivery for sales on or before the settlement date.
## What is a key feature of a margin account?
- [ ] It requires full payment at the time of transaction.
- [x] It allows clients to buy or sell securities using partial credit.
- [ ] It does not permit borrowing for security purchases.
- [ ] It only deals in Government of Canada Treasury bills.
> **Explanation:** A margin account allows clients to buy or sell securities on partial credit, with the investment dealer lending the balance to the client.
## Who provides the credit in a margin account?
- [ ] The client.
- [x] The investment dealer.
- [ ] A government agency.
- [ ] An independent lender.
> **Explanation:** In a margin account, the investment dealer provides credit to the client.
## What is the settlement date for other securities (excluding Government of Canada Treasury bills)?
- [x] Two business days after the transaction.
- [ ] The same day as the transaction.
- [ ] Three business days after the transaction.
- [ ] The day after the transaction.
> **Explanation:** The settlement date for other securities is generally two business days after the transaction.
## On what does the investment dealer base the decision to grant credit in a margin account?
- [ ] The client's personal income.
- [ ] The client's credit score.
- [x] The market value and quality of the securities held in the account.
- [ ] The client's employment status.
> **Explanation:** The investment dealer grants credit based on the market value and quality of the securities held in the margin account.
## What does the client pay in a margin account, aside from a portion of the purchase price?
- [ ] A flat transaction fee.
- [ ] Nothing extra.
- [x] Interest on the loan provided by the investment dealer.
- [ ] A premium fee for using the account.
> **Explanation:** In a margin account, the client pays interest on the loan that the investment dealer provides.
In this section